Old Lady Cat Names. Naming a cat after your (or her) favorite food, like cookie or tuna, can also be a good choice. One of the best ways to pick an old lady name for your precious baby girl is to sit down with a family tree and examine the names of actual old ladies.

Elle is a lovely nickname that feels more modern, but ellie and lea also make perfect nickname choices. So here is the list of over 75 old lady cat names. Then, of course, there are names that people have genuinely stopped using for the last 60 to 100 years — names like agnes, mabel, or naomi.